top of page
Search

When Medicaid Coverage Disappears, the Consequences Don't Stay on Paper

6 days ago
6 min read

Why I'm concerned about the future of healthcare in Geauga and Ashtabula Counties


And if your reply is, "We can't afford healthcare!" - Go "F" off.


By Amy Heutmaker | November 12, 2026


Five days a week, I work as a mental health counselor, helping people navigate some of life's most difficult circumstances. A large percentage of the people I serve rely on Medicaid for their healthcare.


For many, Medicaid is not simply an insurance program. It is what makes treatment possible.

It provides access to mental health counseling, psychiatric medications, addiction treatment, primary care, and other essential services. Just as importantly, it allows people to establish relationships with healthcare professionals and maintain those relationships while working toward stability and recovery.


That is why I am concerned about what is coming on January 1, 2027.


The federal legislation known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed into law in July 2025, makes sweeping changes to Medicaid. Among them are new work-reporting requirements for many adults enrolled through Medicaid expansion, along with eligibility and financing changes that will unfold over the coming years.


Supporters describe these changes as encouraging employment and improving accountability.


But from where I sit, both as a mental health counselor and Russell Township Trustee, I worry that the consequences could be devastating for some of the people who depend on these services.


The Numbers Should Concern All of Us


According to the Health Policy Institute of Ohio's 2025 Medicaid enrollment data:


  • Ashtabula County: 30,566 residents enrolled in Medicaid, representing 31.4% of the population.

  • Geauga County: 8,569 residents enrolled, approximately 9% of the population.


That is more than 39,000 people across our two counties who rely on Medicaid for some or all of their healthcare.


These numbers include children, older adults, people with disabilities, working families, and adults enrolled through Medicaid expansion. Not everyone will be directly subject to the new requirements, but the broader changes could affect healthcare throughout our region.

Geauga County is often viewed as relatively affluent, but countywide averages can hide significant economic hardship. We have families struggling to pay bills, seniors living on fixed incomes, and people working multiple jobs who still cannot afford private health insurance.


Their healthcare matters every bit as much as anyone else's.


What Happens When Someone Loses Access to Mental Healthcare?


In my professional work, I see how much effort it can take for someone experiencing depression, anxiety, trauma, or addiction simply to reach out and begin treatment.

Developing trust takes time. Recovery is rarely a straight line. Consistency matters.

Now imagine someone who has established a therapeutic relationship, begun managing their symptoms, and started making progress.


Then a letter arrives requiring them to verify their Medicaid eligibility.


Perhaps they work irregular hours. Perhaps a psychiatric condition makes it difficult to manage paperwork and deadlines. Or perhaps they lack reliable internet access or transportation.


Under the new requirements, many Medicaid expansion recipients must document at least 80 hours per month of qualifying work, education, training, or community service unless they qualify for an exemption.


People with certain serious health conditions, including qualifying mental health and substance use disorders, may be exempt. But documenting those exemptions can create another obstacle.


My concern is that people who are legally eligible for Medicaid will lose coverage simply because they cannot navigate the administrative process.


When that happens, the consequences extend far beyond an insurance form.

Treatment gets interrupted. Medications become unaffordable. Symptoms worsen. Someone in recovery may lose the support that helped them remain stable.


We should be preventing these outcomes, not creating additional barriers to care.


Nebraska and Montana Are Warning Signs


We already have examples of what can go wrong.


Nebraska and Montana implemented Medicaid work requirements ahead of the January 2027 federal deadline, and their experiences offer troubling lessons.


Recent reporting by KFF Health News describes confusing eligibility notices, administrative problems, overwhelmed assistance systems, and people being denied or losing coverage.

In Nebraska, approximately 1,100 adverse Medicaid eligibility decisions related to work requirements had been reported through August. Most involved people failing to submit requested verification, rather than documented failures to complete qualifying activities.


Montana has experienced similar confusion, with advocates questioning whether state systems and staffing were prepared.


For someone awaiting cancer treatment, managing a psychiatric condition, or receiving medication-assisted treatment for addiction, losing insurance is more than an administrative inconvenience. It can become a healthcare crisis.


Ohio should be learning from these experiences now.


Rural Communities Have Even More to Lose


Geauga and Ashtabula Counties face challenges that are not always apparent in larger metropolitan areas.


Transportation is one. In a rural township, there may be no public bus to a medical appointment. Specialized treatment can require a 30-, 40-, or even 60-minute drive.

Access to behavioral healthcare and addiction treatment can already be difficult. When providers close, reduce services, or stop accepting certain insurance plans, patients have fewer places to turn.


And that brings me to another concern: the financial future of our community hospitals.


An April 2026 report by Public Citizen identified University Hospitals Conneaut Medical Center among hospitals facing heightened financial vulnerability associated with Medicaid reductions.


University Hospitals has stated that Conneaut is not currently at risk of closure, and I want to be clear about that.


Likewise, I have seen no announcement that UH Geauga Medical Center is planning to close. University Hospitals leadership reported earlier this year that the Geauga facility remained financially stable, although financial pressures were increasing.

But closure is not the only concern.


Hospitals can reduce services, eliminate programs, or consolidate care in larger facilities. For rural residents, losing a nearby healthcare service can mean the difference between getting treatment and going without it.


What About Our Children?


I am also concerned about children enrolled in Medicaid and Ohio's Healthy Start program, which includes the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP).


Children are not directly subject to the new Medicaid expansion work requirements. However, they are not insulated from changes affecting their families and healthcare providers.


When a parent loses healthcare coverage, the entire household can experience additional financial and emotional stress. Families may struggle with insurance requirements, while providers facing financial pressures may have fewer resources to serve their communities.

Children need access to pediatric care, vaccinations, developmental screenings, behavioral healthcare, and treatment for chronic conditions.


These are investments in their future and in the future of our communities.


We Need to Pay Attention Now


The Health Policy Institute of Ohio has highlighted projections suggesting that as many as 305,000 Ohioans could lose Medicaid coverage by 2028 because of the new work requirements.


That is a projection, not a certainty. The outcome will depend partly on how Ohio implements the law, communicates with beneficiaries, and processes exemptions.


But even a fraction of that number represents thousands of people facing difficult decisions about their healthcare.


I recognize that public programs need accountability. Government has a responsibility to spend taxpayer dollars wisely. As a township trustee, fiscal responsibility is something I take seriously.


But fiscal responsibility also means understanding the consequences of our decisions.


When people lose access to preventive care, untreated conditions can become medical emergencies. When mental health and addiction treatment are interrupted, the consequences extend to families and communities. And when rural healthcare providers lose revenue, the effects reach well beyond Medicaid recipients.


We need to be asking our state and federal representatives some difficult questions.


How will Ohio ensure eligible people do not lose coverage over paperwork? Are our county Job and Family Services offices prepared for the additional workload? How will people with serious mental health conditions or substance use disorders obtain exemptions? And what are we doing to protect healthcare access in rural communities?


These are not abstract policy questions. They affect our neighbors, our families, and the communities we call home.


Healthcare Should Not Depend on Navigating Bureaucracy


I have spent much of my professional life helping people navigate difficult circumstances. One lesson continues to stand out: meaningful progress requires stability, support, and access to resources.


We cannot reasonably expect people to manage serious medical conditions, recover from addiction, maintain employment, or care for their families while constantly worrying that the healthcare keeping them stable might disappear.


As January 1 approaches, policymakers need to listen to healthcare professionals, hospitals, county agencies, and especially the people who rely on Medicaid.


Those of us in local government also need to remain engaged, even when decisions are made in Columbus or Washington.


Because the consequences will be felt right here.


In Conneaut. In Ashtabula. In Middlefield. In Chardon. In Russell Township.

And throughout Northeast Ohio.


Good government is not measured only by how much money it saves. It must also be measured by how well it serves the people who depend on it.


We owe our neighbors nothing less.


Sources and Further Reading


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Why I'm Still Having the Conversation

Two weeks ago, I cast my vote for Dr. Amy Acton for Governor of Ohio. I did so with serious concerns about how her campaign and the Ohio Democratic Party have handled and continue to handle transgende

 
 
 

Comments


 

© 2025 People for Amy Heutmaker. All rights reserved, no use without permission.

This website is privately operated and does not represent the official communications, policies, or positions of Russell Township or the Board of Trustees.

 

bottom of page